That means Halloween shoppers will be stocking up on classics like Candy Corn, Snickers ($3, Walmart), and Tootsie Pops ($3, Target) more than ever before. To help you decide which goodies to add to your next grocery store pickup, the candy experts at CandyStore.com put together a list of the most popular Halloween candy in every state, based on how many times each candy was purchased over the last several years. Their candy experts looked at sales data from the last 14 years to determine the candy-buying habits of consumers in all 50 states and put together an interactive map of their findings—including the second and third place candies, and the number of pounds of candy sold in each state. While some states’ favorite candies were no surprise (we’re looking at you, Kansas), others will probably have you shaking your head (Montana, really?). If you’re overwhelmed by the number of candies pictured in the map—or if you disagree with your state’s winner—along with the map, the candy experts also included the top Halloween candies nationwide. Over the last 14 years, Reese’s Cups ($11, Walmart) are the top-selling candy during the Halloween season, with Skittles ($3, Target), M&Ms ($4, Walmart), and Starburst ($3, Target) following closely behind. Ready to find out if your state agrees with your candy preferences? Check out the full list below.

These are the top three most-purchased candies in every state.